A 3PL usually makes sense when your own warehouse becomes a bottleneck for growth: when shipping peaks can no longer be handled reliably, space and staff run short, or the team spends more time packing than running the business. The decision should rest on a full-cost comparison per order, including your own time, space, software and error costs, and on clear contractual quality commitments.
What a 3PL does
Third-party logistics providers take over goods-in, storage, picking, packing, shipping and often returns handling. Many also offer value-added services such as kitting, labelling, inserts or gift wrapping. Billing is usually itemised: per inbound delivery, per pallet space or storage volume, per order, per additional item in an order, per return, plus packaging material and postage.
When the switch makes sense
Typical signals in practice:
- shipping peaks, for example during promotions or the Christmas season, regularly cause delays
- the error rate in packing rises with volume
- founders or the core team spend a significant part of the week in the warehouse
- new channels or countries require processes your own warehouse cannot handle
- leases or staffing commitments tie up capital at a stage when flexibility matters more
Conversely, there are good reasons to keep your own warehouse: very specific products, elaborate personalisation, very high volumes with stable processes, or a brand and unboxing experience that a provider cannot deliver reliably.
The cost comparison: full cost per order
Comparisons often fail because only rent and postage are counted on your own side. A fair calculation includes:
| Cost block | Own warehouse | 3PL |
|---|---|---|
| Space | rent, utilities, equipment | storage fee by volume or location |
| Staff | wages, absences, temps at peaks | pick and pack fees |
| Software | warehouse management, integrations | often included, integration may cost extra |
| Shipping | your own rates | 3PL rates, often lower |
| Materials | purchasing, storage | by consumption |
| Errors | wrong shipments, damage | governed by contract |
| Management time | substantial | managing the provider |
Calculate with your real order profile: average items per order, share of bulky parcels, return rate, seasonality. A quote that is cheap for single-item orders can become expensive for multi-item orders.
Selection criteria beyond price
Fit with your range
A 3PL specialised in small, standard parcels is not automatically good for glass, dangerous goods, food or furniture. Ask for clients with similar products and have the processes shown to you on site.
Integrations
The connection to your shop, marketplaces and inventory system decides what everyday life looks like. Check whether stock is synchronised in real time or at intervals, how shipping confirmations and tracking numbers flow back and how errors are reported.
Marketplace capability
If you sell on Amazon with merchant fulfilment, you need a provider who reliably meets the shipping requirements. More on the trade-off between Amazon logistics and your own shipping in Amazon FBA or FBM.
Scalability and peaks
Ask specifically how peaks are covered, whether there are cut-off times and what happens if volume rises sharply at short notice.
International handling
For sales to other countries, locations, customs expertise and carrier partners matter. See also Selling Across EU Borders.
What matters in the contract
- Service levels: same-day dispatch up to a defined cut-off, error rate, processing time for returns and goods-in.
- Liability: for inventory discrepancies, damage and wrong shipments, with clear limits.
- Stock counts: frequency, procedure, handling of discrepancies.
- Term and termination: minimum terms, notice periods and, above all, the rules for releasing your goods when the contract ends.
- Price changes: under what conditions the provider may raise prices.
- Data protection: customer data is processed, so a data processing agreement is required.
Have the contract reviewed by a lawyer before signing, particularly liability provisions and any lien over stored goods.
Onboarding without a drop in sales
- Clean up master data: barcodes, dimensions, weights, packaging units.
- Test integrations in a test environment with real test orders.
- Plan the move outside peak season.
- Run a transition with parallel stock or a short, announced shipping pause.
- Check metrics daily in the first weeks: dispatch time, errors, queries.
Checklist
- full cost per order for your own warehouse determined
- quotes made comparable using your real order profile
- references with a similar range checked and site visited
- integrations tested technically
- service levels, liability and exit terms fixed in the contract
- onboarding plan with time buffer
Want to check this for your business in concrete terms? Have a look at e-commerce consulting. See also: inventory planning.
Want to go through this with your numbers?
Tell me briefly how your shop is set up today. In the initial call we look at contribution margin and the biggest levers.
Book an initial call E-Commerce & MarketingFAQ
At how many orders does a 3PL pay off?
There is no fixed threshold. Full costs, the complexity of the range and the value of the time your team spends in the warehouse are what count. Some retailers switch early so they can focus on growth.
Can I run several channels through one 3PL?
Yes, most providers serve the shop, marketplaces and B2B orders from one pool of stock. The integrations with every channel need to work reliably.
What happens to my stock if the provider becomes insolvent?
That depends on the contract and the applicable law. Set out ownership, release of goods and stock count records clearly, and take legal advice on this point.
How long does a move to a 3PL take?
With preparation, integration testing and inbounding, plan for several weeks. More buffer is better than moving shortly before peak season.