Invictus Global Consult Book a call

Amazon & Marketplaces

Amazon FBA or FBM: Decision Criteria for Brands

By René Schubert8 min readPublished: November 20, 2026
Short answer

FBA usually pays off for small, fast-moving items, FBM often for bulky, slow-moving ones. Decide per item on full cost, not per account. Fee values change, so calculate with the current tables from Seller Central.

FBA (Fulfilment by Amazon) usually pays off for small to medium-sized, fast-moving products where Prime visibility and fast delivery make the difference. FBM (fulfilment by merchant) is often the better choice for bulky, slow-moving or low-margin items, for products with special shipping requirements and for sellers who want to manage stock flexibly across several channels. Many brands do best with a hybrid approach, deciding per product rather than per account.

The two models at a glance

With FBA, you send stock to Amazon's fulfilment centres. Amazon handles storage, picking, shipping, delivery-related customer service and returns. In return you pay fulfilment fees per unit, storage fees by volume and time and, for longer storage, additional fees. Offers are generally Prime-eligible automatically.

With FBM, you store and ship yourself or through a provider. You have full control over packaging, carriers and stock. In return you have to meet Amazon's shipping and delivery performance requirements reliably. Prime eligibility is possible through a separate programme if the requirements are met.

Criterion 1: Cost per product

The most important step is a full-cost calculation per item. For FBA: fulfilment fee, monthly storage fees, inbound costs to Amazon's warehouse, any capacity or long-term storage fees and return costs. For FBM: storage costs, pick and pack, packaging, postage, returns handling and the cost of your own or outsourced customer service.

Product profile Tendency
small, light, fast-moving FBA often cheaper and faster
bulky or heavy FBM frequently more economical
slow-moving FBM, to avoid storage fees
seasonal with short peaks FBA in season, otherwise FBM
fragile or with special packaging FBM for more control

The calculation belongs in the contribution margin model per channel. Only then can you see whether an item is profitable on FBA at all.

The fee mechanics to watch

Amazon publishes the FBA fees in a rate card that is adjusted regularly (the version cited for Europe applies from 2 November 2026). The actual amounts change, the mechanics stay:

  • Size and weight: for the fulfilment fee, besides actual weight a dimensional weight counts, calculated as length × width × height in centimetres divided by 5,000. A large, light item becomes more expensive than its weight suggests.
  • Monthly storage fee: it is based on the volume occupied (cubic metres) and the storage time.
  • Surcharges: for long-stored stock and for high storage utilisation relative to sales, Amazon charges additional fees.

A simple rule follows from the mechanics: FBA rewards items that are small and sell fast. Bulky and slow items pay several times, once through volume, then through storage time.

Criterion 2: Visibility and conversion

Prime offers have an advantage in conversion and the Buy Box in many categories. Customers filter by Prime, and fast delivery promises increase the likelihood of purchase. With FBM, part of the disadvantage can be offset if delivery times are short and the shipping template is well maintained. Offering Prime with your own shipping means meeting the performance requirements permanently, which is organisationally demanding.

Worked example: the same method, two products (constructed)

The following amounts are assumptions for illustration and not Amazon fee values. Figures are per unit, net.

Item A: small, fast-moving B: bulky, slow-moving
Selling price net €25.00 €120.00
Purchase cost €8.00 €55.00
Referral fee (assumed 15%) €3.75 €18.00
FBA: fulfilment fee €3.50 €22.00
FBA: storage fee per unit €0.20 €6.00
FBA: returns cost €0.80 €3.00
Contribution margin FBA €8.75 (35%) €16.00 (13%)
FBM: shipping, pick and pack, packaging €6.50 €20.00
FBM: returns and customer service €1.60 €4.00
Contribution margin FBM €5.15 (21%) €23.00 (19%)

For item A, FBA brings €3.60 more per unit, for item B, FBM brings €7.00 more. An account model that treats both items alike gives money away. With your own numbers you can reproduce this for your range in a spreadsheet. That includes the question of how many weeks stock sits on average, because storage cost depends on it.

Criterion 3: Capacity and predictability

Amazon limits how much stock sellers can hold in FBA and adjusts these limits regularly. Fast-growing sellers or those needing large seasonal quantities can hit them. Inbound processing times can also lengthen at peak periods. Without reliable inventory planning, stockouts follow that cost ranking and revenue.

FBM gives more certainty over your own stock but requires warehouse and shipping to perform reliably at peaks too.

Criterion 4: Control and brand

With FBA you hand over packaging and the returns process. For many products this is unproblematic. For premium brands where unboxing is part of the experience, or for products that are often returned in poor condition and restocked incorrectly, FBM can have advantages. With FBM, the same stock can also be used more easily across channels, such as your own shop, other marketplaces and B2B. More in Multichannel in Germany.

FBM: metrics you have to meet permanently

Anyone who ships themselves is assessed on performance metrics. In its account health documents Amazon names target values, for example for the pre-fulfilment cancellation rate (below 2.5 percent), the late shipment rate (below 4 percent) and the share of valid tracking (at least 95 percent). Amazon adjusts these values and they differ by programme and marketplace. Check the current targets in Seller Central and plan your logistics with distance to them, not at the limit.

This raises questions for your own operation:

  • Can the warehouse meet the dispatch time you state, even in peak weeks?
  • Does the carrier supply tracking that Amazon accepts?
  • Who answers customer enquiries within the required deadlines?

A provider can take this load. Then the choice belongs in the full-cost comparison, see Outsourcing Fulfilment.

Criterion 5: Risk

With FBA your stock sits in Amazon's network. Inventory discrepancies and damaged or lost units have to be resolved through reimbursement claims, which takes time. If there are account problems, stock is also harder to access. Keeping part of your stock outside Amazon reduces this risk; see also Amazon Account Suspension.

Setting up a pilot properly

Instead of switching the whole range, test with a few items:

  1. Pick five to ten items covering different profiles: small and fast, large and slow, seasonal.
  2. Measure before: contribution margin, conversion, Buy Box share, return rate.
  3. Run for eight to twelve weeks so that storage time and returns become visible.
  4. Compare afterwards and decide per item. Document the decision with date and figures.
  5. Repeat quarterly, because fees, competition and your volumes change.

Mind the practicalities of the switch: goods must be prepared, labelled and delivered to the warehouses Amazon assigns, following its requirements. Mistakes in labelling or packaging delay receiving and cost selling days.

The hybrid strategy

In practice, deciding per product and season works well:

  1. Core bestsellers on FBA, with safety stock in your own or a provider's warehouse.
  2. Bulky and slow-moving items on FBM.
  3. Backup FBM offers for FBA items to step in during shortages, where account settings and categories allow.
  4. Seasonal switching: more FBA at peak, moving back afterwards.

An external provider can handle the FBM side; see Outsourcing Fulfilment.

Checklist

  • full cost of FBA and FBM calculated per item
  • stock turn per item known
  • effects on Buy Box and conversion monitored
  • FBA capacity limits factored into inventory planning
  • backup for bestsellers outside Amazon
  • regular review of reimbursements and inventory discrepancies
  • decision per item documented and reviewed quarterly

If you want to run this with your own numbers, I can help in Amazon and marketplaces.

Note: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice. For advice on your specific situation, please consult a lawyer or tax adviser.

Is your marketplace business running as it should?

Tell me which platform and which problem. I will tell you plainly whether and how I can help.

Book an initial call E-Commerce & Marketing

FAQ

Is FBA always better for ranking?

Not automatically. Prime eligibility and delivery promises affect conversion and the Buy Box, which in turn affects ranking. An FBM offer with fast, reliable delivery can also rank well.

Can you use FBA and FBM for the same product?

Depending on the account, category and current rules, this is possible, for example through separate offers. Check the applicable policies in Seller Central before setting it up.

What exactly does FBA cost?

Fees depend on size, weight, category and storage duration and are adjusted by Amazon regularly. Use the current fee schedules and the revenue calculator in Seller Central for your items.

Is Seller Fulfilled Prime worth it?

For sellers with very reliable, fast logistics it can be. The requirements are demanding and must be met permanently, otherwise participation ends.

How does Amazon calculate dimensional weight?

According to the European rate card as length × width × height in centimetres divided by 5,000. Which weight counts for the fee is stated in the current rate card.

Which numbers should I know before deciding?

Selling price, purchase cost, referral fee, FBA fee, storage time, return rate and your costs under FBM. Without storage time the calculation is misleading for slow-moving items.

Sources

As of November 2026. Fees and target values change, so check the current information in Seller Central.

René Schubert
René Schubert is Managing Member of Invictus Global Consult and advises online retailers, brands and property owners from Berlin. He has built his own brands and marketplace businesses.

Further reading