A good assortment strategy in e-commerce usually means fewer products that are more clearly positioned, more reliably in stock and deliver more contribution margin per euro tied up. The way there runs through an analysis by revenue, contribution margin and stock turn, clear roles for every product, and a fixed procedure for adding and delisting items.
Why ranges sprawl
Ranges almost always grow faster than revenue. Every new colour, every additional size and every product "to try out" seems sensible on its own. Together they produce a range in which capital is tied up in slow-moving stock, bestsellers sell out more often because the buying budget is gone, and the team spends time maintaining items that hardly sell.
There is also an effect that is often overlooked online: more choice does not necessarily make deciding easier for customers. Too many similar variants can even reduce conversion.
Step 1: Analysis on three axes
A classic ABC analysis by revenue is not enough. A view on three axes is more useful:
| Axis | Question | Data source |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | What share of revenue does the item carry? | shop, marketplaces |
| Contribution margin | What remains after all variable costs? | margin model |
| Stock turn | How quickly does inventory sell through? | inventory system |
An item with high revenue and negative contribution is a different problem from an item with good contribution and very slow turnover. For the calculation, see contribution margin in e-commerce.
A helpful metric is contribution margin per unit of capital tied up in stock over a period. It shows which products earn the best return on the money invested.
Step 2: Assign roles in the range
Not every product has to do the same job. A division into roles works well:
- Core products: carry revenue and margin, must always be in stock.
- Entry products: win new customers, often at a lower margin but with a high likelihood of repurchase.
- Complementary products: increase basket size and give a reason for the next purchase.
- Profile products: sharpen the brand, even if they do not sell the largest volumes.
- Test products: deliberately limited quantities, with a clear success criterion and an end date.
Items that cannot be assigned to any role are candidates for delisting.
Step 3: Reduce variants
Variants are often the biggest lever. For each product, check:
- Which colours and sizes account for most of the volume?
- Are there variants that sell almost only during promotions?
- Which variants cause above-average returns?
Reducing variants does not automatically lower supplier minimum order quantities, but it improves availability, clarity and planning. On marketplaces it also concentrates reviews and visibility.
Step 4: Delist systematically
Delisting rarely fails because of the analysis; it fails at the decision. A fixed process helps:
- Quarterly list of candidates based on the three axes
- Check whether price, a bundle or a channel change could solve the problem
- Decision with a date from which nothing is reordered
- Sell-through plan for remaining stock: own promotion, bundle, outlet, B2B buyers
- Documentation, so the item does not reappear a year later
On marketplaces, check before delisting whether the listing can continue to be used for other variants or bundles.
Step 5: Tie new additions to criteria
A filter for new products matters just as much as delisting. Every addition should answer in advance:
- What role will the item play?
- What contribution margin is realistic, including logistics and marketing?
- What minimum quantity has to be bought, and how long will it last?
- How will you know after three or six months whether it stays?
What a structured launch looks like is described in Planning a Product Launch.
Impact on liquidity
A leaner range frees up capital that can go into the availability of core products, into marketing or into new, well-prepared products. For retailers with growth ambitions this is often the cheapest route to more liquidity. The interplay with inventory planning is covered in Inventory Planning for Marketplace Sellers.
Checklist
- analysis by revenue, contribution margin and stock turn
- contribution per unit of capital tied up, for every item
- roles in the range defined
- variants reviewed by volume and returns
- quarterly delisting process with a sell-through plan
- clear criteria for new additions
- results fed into purchase planning
For own brands, it is also worth reading Building a Private Label. You will find my offer for your situation under e-commerce consulting. Feel free to write me a short note.
Want to go through this with your numbers?
Tell me briefly how your shop is set up today. In the initial call we look at contribution margin and the biggest levers.
Book an initial call E-Commerce & MarketingFAQ
How many products should an online shop have?
There is no right number. What matters is that every item has a role and justifies its capital. Specialised brands often manage with very few products.
Don't you lose revenue when you delist?
Sometimes a little in the short term. Often part of the demand moves to related items, and the freed-up capital improves bestseller availability. Measure the effect on total contribution margin.
How often should the range be reviewed?
A quarterly review is a good rhythm for most retailers, with an additional review before each buying round for strongly seasonal ranges.
What should you do with leftover stock?
Depending on the goods: bundles, your own clearance promotions, outlet channels or sales to B2B buyers. Decide early, before the goods lose value.